Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Zhuangzi's The Old Wheelwright

 













This parable by Zhuangzi teaches us that 
knowledge that is written down is not the full knowledge. It is only the Blueprint. The practical workings are not all written down. That is called "Tacit Knowledge".
In 2011, NASA wanted to see if they could modernize the 1960s F-1 engine to use as a booster for the Space Launch System (SLS). A small team of young NASA engineers retrieved a vintage F-1 engine (Serial Number F-6049) from storage—along with a gas generator from the Smithsonian—and pulled the original 1960s blueprints from the archives. When they compared the original paper blueprints to the physical engine in front of them, they discovered that they could not simply build a working engine from the drawings alone.
During the 1960s space race, Rocketdyne engineers and technicians were working under intense deadline pressure without modern CAD software. As a result, the blueprints didn't tell the whole story:
  • Hand-Crafted Modifications. Every single F-1 engine was essentially hand-built by master machinists and welders. During assembly and hot-fire testing, technicians would encounter fit issues, vibration problems, or combustion instabilities.
  • Undocumented Field Fixes. Instead of halting production to redraw and re-approve blueprints, master welders and engineers made on-the-fly adjustments directly on the shop floor. They rerouted tubing, tweaked welds, and even hand-drilled slight variations into the fuel injector plates to stop dangerous pressure oscillations.
  • Every Engine Was Unique. Because these fixes were treated as "tacit knowledge" among the technicians rather than formal blueprint updates, no two F-1 engines were completely identical. Each engine had its own undocumented quirks.There are still many other equipment in our modern world, such as the giant high-voltage transformers, with lifespans of many decades that are practically unique items.

The other point made in the parable was the Master - Apprentice relationship. The apprentice is able to learn, observe and practice during his apprenticeship. If this is not maintained, the skills will be lost when the Master passed. This was brought out in my 28 October 2026 post Three Case Studies on Maintenance.




Sunday, November 15, 2026

Fukushima Nuclear Reactor Disaster - A Case Study.

 

How it Happened 

The Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster began on March 11, 2011, after a massive magnitude 9.0 earthquake and a tsunami up to 15-meter struck Japan's coast, disabling the plant's cooling systems and causing three nuclear meltdowns. Operated by the Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO), it is rated Level 7 on the International Nuclear Event Scale, making it the worst nuclear accident since Chernobyl.


The Sequence of The Main Events

Phase 1: The Earthquake and Tsunami (March 11, 2011). At 2:46 pm the earthquake struck and the three operating reactors went into automatic shutdown. There was a loss of external power supply, the emergency diesel backup generators were started automatically to maintain the water cooling system for the reactor cores. The tsunami struck about 50 minutes later flooding the turbine buildings destroying 12 of the 13 backup generators. The blackout caused the loss of cooling, monitoring and control.

Phase 2: As the remaining water inside Reactors 1, 2, and 3 evaporated, the nuclear fuel rods were exposed and meltdown occurred. The hydrogen gas produced was vented out of reactor vessels into the buildings. The buildings housing Units 1 and 3 exploded, as did Unit 4 (from hydrogen that migrated from Unit 3) between 12 to 15 March.

Phase 3: Evacuation of all civilians within a 20 kilometer radius. The company restored power, built a cold water recycled loop until the Japanese Government declared a stable cold shutdown was achieved in December 2011. The full cleanup and decommission will take an estimated 30 - 40 years.


The Two Major Reports

The Parliamentary Commission Report (July 2012). Headed by Kiyoshi Kurokawa, the National Diet of Japan Fukushima Nuclear Accident Independent Investigation Commission (NAIIC) famously concluded that the disaster was "man-made" rather than solely a natural catastrophe. Kurokawa wrote that its root causes lay in regulatory capture, collusion between government, regulators, and the plant operator (TEPCO), and ingrained cultural norms of "reflexive obedience" to authority and the habit of Japanese organizations to avoid questioning superiors.

The IAEA Final Report (August 2015). Compiled by roughly 180 international experts and released by Director General Yukiya Amano, the IAEA Fukushima Daiichi Accident Report attributed the disaster to a widespread "assumption of absolute safety" in Japan. The report found that regulators and operators believed nuclear plants were inherently safe against severe natural events, leading to inadequate tsunami defenses, fragmented emergency response protocols, and weak regulatory oversight.


Specific Shortcomings Reported in The Reports

Ancient Japanese imperial chronicles on the year 869 CE—specifically the Nihon Sandai Jitsuroku—recorded that a massive earthquake struck the Tohoku coast, followed by a towering tsunami that swept kilometers inland and drowned roughly 1,000 people. When Fukushima Daiichi was designed in the 1960s, engineers based tsunami projections mainly on recent historical records (such as the 1960 Chilean earthquake) rather than ancient chronicles. TEPCO and regulators dismissed older records like the 869 Jōgan event and other sediment studies as imprecise or irrelevant to the specific stretch of coastline near Fukushima.

The investigation reports revealed that TEPCO actually ran its own computer simulations in 2008 based on the government's seismic warnings and the 869 Jōgan data. TEPCO's internal engineers calculated that a tsunami triggered by a major offshore earthquake could reach 15.7 meters at the Fukushima Daiichi site—nearly triple the plant's 5.7-meter seawall. No upgrades to the defensive seawalls were done at that time pending a further study.

When TEPCO constructed Fukushima Daiichi in the late 1960s, executives intentionally excavated the coastal bluff down by 25 meters—lowering the site ground level to just 10 meters (33 feet) above sea level. According to post-disaster testimonies and engineering records from the 1960s, TEPCO made this decision primarily to save on construction and ongoing electricity costs.
This is what the Machine looks like in concrete form: not a conspiracy, but a series of individually rational decisions, each defensible in isolation, that collectively produced a catastrophe.

The NAIIC Report can be downloaded from https://www.nirs.org/wp-content/uploads/fukushima/naiic_report.pdf




The IAEA Director General's report can be downloaded from https://www-pub.iaea.org/mtcd/publications/pdf/pub1710-reportbythedg-web.pdf


The Onagawa Nuclear Power Plant and Yanosuke Hirai

The story of the Onagawa Nuclear Power Plant in Miyagi Prefecture is worth telling. Yanosuke Hirai was a civil engineer and Vice President of Tohoku Electric Power Company. Despite sitting much closer to the earthquake's epicenter than Fukushima Daiichi—and taking a direct hit from a 13-meter (43-foot) tsunami—Onagawa suffered no core damage.

He had studied the past records, especially the 869 Jōgan event and valued its implications in contrast to TEPCO's reading of them. He went against his company engineers to insist on a 14.8m seawall and raising the site.


Path Dependency, The Machine's Incentives, and The Machine's Blindspots.

Fukushima is one instance. The broader pattern is this: actors whose position depends on the current path have incentives to dismiss challenges to it—and 'inconclusive' is one of the cheapest labels available for that dismissal."

The above is a case study in the distinction between active lock-in and passive path dependency. TEPCO didn't just face switching costs; it suppressed evidence that would have justified switching.

The Machine is our creation. It created the actors—bankers, consultants, lawyers, brokers—who operate within the laws, the corporations, and the current ecosystem, and who make a financial model yield a high ROI.

The consultants (e.g. engineering, architectural, accounting, taxation, legal) give the favorable assumptions that work for the project approval.

The present regime may not be easily changed. It may require more than incremental reform. My main contention is the unintended result of protecting the status quo ossifies our world's future progress. The regime's defenders did not need to call the Jōgan evidence a conspiracy; they simply needed to call it 'inconclusive', which is the more effective form of dismissal.

The same logic applies beyond Fukushima: challenges to consensus are often dismissed with a label rather than an argument. Not all conspiracy theories are right, but neither are they all wrong. Instead they should be treated as challenges to current consensus, worthy of due consideration.

Hence the value of the saying "Throwing Out The Baby With The Bath Water". The "Baby" could be a proposed safer form of nuclear reactor. The arguably safer thorium molten salt reactor is an example. A comprehensive evacuation plan for the worse case scenario (where the assumptions used are challenged). These might be discarded by the present regime as they don't fit within its assumptions.



Thursday, November 12, 2026

Path Dependency: How 1612 and 1855 Built the Debt Machine.

 


Path Dependency (coined by economists like Paul David in his 1985 QWERTY paper and W. Brian Arthur's 1989 Economic Journal piece), explains how choices made in the past limit the choices available in the present.


Path dependency usually means we stay on a path because switching is costly. This post argues something stronger: that the regime is actively defended by actors who profit from it.


The key point in the past was when Debt Financing became the major factor. When and how it happened is the interesting question.


Imagine you are in The Era of Pure Shareholder Financing (c. 1000 – 1612)


During the High Middle Ages and the Age of Discovery, long-distance trade operated almost entirely on upfront, risk-sharing equity contracts rather than long-term corporate debt.


The Medieval Era (11th–15th Centuries)


Originating in Italian maritime cities like Venice and Genoa was the single-voyage partnership. A sedentary investor put up 100% of the upfront capital, while a traveling merchant risked their life and labor. If the ship sank, the investor lost their gold and the merchant owed nothing. If it succeeded, profits were split (typically 75% to the investor, 25% to the merchant), and the contract dissolved.


Usury Prohibitions Reinforced Equity


The Catholic Church strictly banned charging interest (usury) during the Middle Ages, though many workarounds existed; most financiers therefore structured investments as equity partnerships rather than interest-bearing debt.


Early Joint-Stock Voyages (1550s–1612)


Early expeditions like the English Muscovy Company (1555), the English East India Company (1600)  pooled upfront equity from dozens of merchants for a single voyage. When the ships returned to port, the spices were auctioned, capital and profits were distributed, and the ledger was wiped clean.



Then came The Turning Point: Permanent Capital & Debt (1612 – 1700s)


The end of the pure, single-venture equity era began in the early 17th century when global trade required permanent forts, standing navies, and multi-year supply chains that a single voyage could not fund.

Founded in 1602, the Dutch East India Company (VOC) was expected to liquidate its capital after 10 years. In 1612, the directors refused to pay back the initial capital, locking the equity into the company permanently. Because investors could no longer cash out at the end of a voyage, the Amsterdam Stock Exchange became a secondary market where shares were traded.

Once companies gained "perpetual life," they could borrow money against future decades of revenue. By 1617, the VOC began  borrowing against future revenue to fund warfare and expansion. Similarly, the English East India Company abandoned per-voyage accounting for permanent capital in 1657, opening the floodgates to long-term debt financing.


Finally came The Birth of Modern Limited Liability (1811 – 1855)


Before the 19th century, incorporating a company with limited liability required a special royal charter or an act of parliament—typically reserved for state-backed monopolies. Ordinary businesses operated as partnerships with unlimited liability, meaning if a business took on debt and failed, creditors could seize the owners' personal homes and throw them in debtors' prison.

Because personal ruin was on the line, ordinary business owners avoided massive long-term debt until the law changed:


1811 (The First General Law). New York State passed An Act Relative to Incorporations For Manufacturing Purposes. The world's first law allowing ordinary manufacturing businesses to incorporate with limited liability without needing a special legislative favor, though it was heavily restricted in scope to specific essential goods used in manufacturing. It also specified certain pro-rata liability.


1855 (The Industrial Floodgate). In Britain, the heart of the Industrial Revolution, the Limited Liability Act 1855 (followed by the Joint Stock Companies Act 1856) made limited liability available to the general public. Parliament initially resisted this fiercely, fearing that shielding owners from debt would destroy business morality and encourage reckless speculation.


This is The Pivot Point to our present regime. 1612 made permanent debt possible; 1855 made it safe for ordinary owners. The two together—not either alone—built the regime we live in. Once 1855 disconnected the personal wealth of shareholders from the debts of the corporation, borrowing larger sums of money became available to the individuals running the enterprise. 



The Well-intentioned Laws, Working as Designed


The Machine's Incentives

Executives have a fiduciary duty to maximize shareholder value. Even if a CEO wants to slow down, accept lower profits, or acknowledge ecological and social limits, the system will discourage it. Wall Street replaces him with someone who will keep the growth projections alive. Such behavior is rational in the present regime; it is a job requirement.

The ecosystem including for example bankers, consultants, lawyers, brokers, and FinTech do not produce physical goods like food or shelter; they extract fees by managing the friction and complexity of the debt machine.

Investment bankers and brokers profit by packaging future assumptions into tradable debt (bonds, derivatives, securitized loans). The bigger the debt, the bigger their upfront fee.

Management consultants provide the "expert" spreadsheets and mathematical justification that validate the regime's unrealistic assumptions, giving executives plausible deniability when things fail.

Corporate lawyers build the intricate shields of limited liability, shell companies, and tax havens that ensure the sponsors keep the upside while the public absorbs the downside.

The latest layer, FinTech, using algorithms and high-frequency digital rails to accelerate the velocity of debt and credit, making extraction instantaneous and frictionless.



The Machine's Blind Spots


We built an immortal, limited-liability machine powered by mortal humans with unlimited desires. The economic geographer Bent Flyvbjerg wrote about Strategic Misrepresentation as the deliberate, systematic distortion of project data—underestimating costs and overestimating benefits—to get a project approved and financed. He recognized the possible cognitive bias of optimism. The deliberate version matters here because it is rational under the current regime—understating costs is how projects get financed.

To make a financial model yield a high ROI, engineers and financial analysts systematically delete "fat-tail" events (rare, catastrophic, once-in-a-millennium disasters) from their spreadsheets. All decision-making (especially with the long-term commitments) requires certainty in assumptions. The consultants (e.g. engineering, architectural, accounting, taxation, legal) give definitive conclusions.


These are all instances of individual rationality—a banker whose bonus is paid on origination volume has no incentive to price tail risk—distinct from systemic outcomes such as fragility and fat-tail blindness. These are goals that are allowed under our current regime of law, finance, economics, and consultancy. 

We should note that these actors do provide system wide benefits such as liquidity provision and risk pooling. The greater number of participants does markedly increase the ability to finance the projects and also spread—though not necessarily reduce—the risks across multiple financiers.



The ROI (Return On Investment) to the individuals is positive. But consider Joseph Tainter, whose 1988 book The Collapse of Complex Societies says the initial complexities are highly rewarding —the first bridge across a river returns far more than the fiftieth. Tainter's thesis is contested; complexity sometimes buys resilience. Has the current ROI for our civilization turned negative?


Are the enterprise and project debt-financing stretching decades into the future a form of restriction that prevents a change of course? Since practically all paradigm changes will negatively affect the actors above?





(We will examine an interesting example on the Fukushima Nuclear Reactor in the next post. We will ask if the rigidity against new alternative paradigms, in our current regime, may put us in danger of "throwing out the baby with the bath water"?)




Monday, November 09, 2026

The Fourth Turning - The Current Cycle.

 

Neil Howe


The Authors and The Books


The Fourth Turning (1997)

Neil Howe and William Strauss


The Fourth Turning Is Here (2023)

Neil Howe


How To Prepare For The End of The World (As We Know It) (2027) Neil Howe



When you read The Fourth Turning, it can be confusing trying to keep the components of their theory apart:


  • There are many cycles from the past till our current cycle. I have focused on the one immediate previous cycle and our current one (labelled as P and C)
  • There are 4 archetypes, basically the 4 generations active in each cycle. You can think of them as "Oldies", "Mature Adults", "Young Adults", and "Teens and younger" (hence the P1 to P4, and C1 to C4).
  • There are many dates in the book. One set are the dates (range of year of birth) for each of the P1 - P4, and the C1 - C4.
  • Another set of dates (range of year) for each Turning in our Current Cycle.



The Previous Cycle


1865 - 1946

  • P1 The Prophet Generation (Missionary) born 1860 to 1882. 
  • P2 The Nomad Generation (Lost) born 1883 to 1900
  • P3 The Hero Generation (G.I.) born 1901 to 1924
  • P4 The Artist Generation (Silent) born 1925 to 1942



The Current Cycle


1946 - early 2030


  • C1 The Prophet Generation (Boomers) Those born 1943 to 1960. Values-driven, visionary, provoking the crisis through cultural rebellion.
  • C2 The Nomad Generation (Gen X) Those born 1961 to 1981 Pragmatic, survival-oriented, managing institutions through the chaos.
  • C3 The Hero Generation (Millennials) Those born 1982 to 2004
  • C4 The Artist Generation (Gen Z) Those born 2005 to present



The Four Turnings in This Cycle are:


The First Turning (1946 - 1964)

The Second Turning (1964 - 1984)

The Third Turning (1984 - 2008)

The Fourth Turning (2008 - early 2030s)



In The Fourth Turning of The Previous Cycle in 1929 - 1946.

  • The world of WW2 (1939 - 1945) was started by the last group of the previous cycle. The P1 Prophet  Group, the 60 - 80 year olds. They were the Kings, the Presidents, and the governments. Their values clashed amongst nations driving the crisis. 
  • The machineries of governance were led by a mix of P1 Prophet and P2 Nomad Groups, the 40 - 60 year olds. The Generals and senior officers, the senior bureaucrats of governments, and the senior corporate management.
  • The war was mainly fought by the soldiers of the P3 Hero Group, the 20 - 40 year olds.
  • The kids in P4 grew up in war time.



In The Fourth Turning of Our Current Cycle in 2008 - early 2030s.


Our world is led by The C1 Prophet (Boomer) Group of the now 60 - 80 year olds. Its their values that drive world events from politics to economics. 

  • Their Role in the Crisis: Elders and Visionary Leaders. Entering elderhood, they transition from the cultural rebels of their youth into the stern, uncompromising leaders of the crisis. They provide the overarching moral direction, values, and ideological framework for the struggle—acting as the "wise old men and women" or the stubborn dogmatists driving the polarization. They are the Senior politicians, judges, community elders, religious leaders, cultural commentators, and institutional directors


The machineries of governance and commerce are led by the 40 - 60 year olds P2 (Nomads). 

  • Their Role in the Crisis: Midlife Managers and Pragmatic Fixers. Nomads become the hands-on, cynical, yet highly resourceful "repair generation". While Prophets argue over morals and ideology, Nomads are focused entirely on survival, utility, and execution. They are the ones tasked with keeping the physical infrastructure and economy running under extreme stress. They are the military officers, supply chain logistics directors, engineering field supervisors, emergency responders, and pragmatic small-business owners.


The "soldiers" of our current Fourth Turning is the 20 - 40 year olds of the P3 (Hero) Group.

  • Their Role in the Crisis: Young Adult Workers and Civic Soldiers. Coming of age during the Unraveling and entering adulthood in the Crisis, Heroes are characterized by teamwork, optimism, and civic duty. They are the boots-on-the-ground force that rallies behind institutional rebuilding. They are highly cooperative and look to solve massive collective problems rather than pursuing individualistic goals. They are the Soldiers, front-line healthcare workers, community organizers, technology builders, infrastructure workers, and collective civic action leaders.

The babies of our current Fourth Turning are The Artist Generation (GenZ), those aged below 20.

  • Their Role in the Crisis: Protected Children and Adaptive Helpers. Because the world outside is in complete chaos during a Fourth Turning, the adults (Nomads and Prophets) fiercely overprotect this youngest generation. As children and early teens during the crisis, their job is to be cooperative, obedient, and emotionally supportive to their stressed families. They grow up to be highly empathetic, process-oriented, and detail-driven. These are the students, family helpers, and eventually, early-career consensus builders, experts, and process oriented professionals.


What Is The Likely outcome? What will be the World of 2030?


Neil Howe (and William Strauss, who died in 2007) used qualitative analyses of past histories (mainly US history) to develop the Social Generations approach for a recurring cycle.


His works in, The Fourth Turning, The Fourth Turning Is Here, and the upcoming How Do We Prepare For The End Of The World (As We Know It), is on how our Current Fourth Turning will develop and more importantly, his hope that The Next Cycle will bring a new beginning. Each generation taking over in each next turning have different (but repeated from previous cycles) views, beliefs, values and ways of social interactions.


In my opinion, the one basic assumption he makes (he's not doomer) is that we have not screwed up our world to such an extent in this current cycle such that the reset to the next cycle may kill most of us?


What do You think? Will this time be different?






(Howe avoids pinpointing an exact year, but his sequel points to the early 2030s as the likely climax. They posit that history rhymes.


I hope this post helps to encourage the reader to read the author's full books. A lot more details about the past cycles are in the first book. The second one focuses on the current Fourth Turning with updated details. The forthcoming book obviously will interest anyone wishing to prepare.)






Saturday, November 07, 2026

Best Travel, Leaving No Tracks.

 


This chapter in The Daodejing by Laozi covers the ease of Wu Wei. The word "Good" here is used as one who follows The Dao.



In Tsai Chih-Chung's Laozi Speaks, it's called "Sagely Conservation". The best effortless way of action.

















"The Good person is just The One Who Follows The Dao". The one "not good" is just the one who hasn't yet follow The Dao.






Wu Wei allows you to see, accept and learn from everyone.