Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Zhuangzi's The Old Wheelwright

 













This parable by Zhuangzi teaches us that 
knowledge that is written down is not the full knowledge. It is only the Blueprint. The practical workings are not all written down. That is called "Tacit Knowledge".
In 2011, NASA wanted to see if they could modernize the 1960s F-1 engine to use as a booster for the Space Launch System (SLS). A small team of young NASA engineers retrieved a vintage F-1 engine (Serial Number F-6049) from storage—along with a gas generator from the Smithsonian—and pulled the original 1960s blueprints from the archives. When they compared the original paper blueprints to the physical engine in front of them, they discovered that they could not simply build a working engine from the drawings alone.
During the 1960s space race, Rocketdyne engineers and technicians were working under intense deadline pressure without modern CAD software. As a result, the blueprints didn't tell the whole story:
  • Hand-Crafted Modifications. Every single F-1 engine was essentially hand-built by master machinists and welders. During assembly and hot-fire testing, technicians would encounter fit issues, vibration problems, or combustion instabilities.
  • Undocumented Field Fixes. Instead of halting production to redraw and re-approve blueprints, master welders and engineers made on-the-fly adjustments directly on the shop floor. They rerouted tubing, tweaked welds, and even hand-drilled slight variations into the fuel injector plates to stop dangerous pressure oscillations.
  • Every Engine Was Unique. Because these fixes were treated as "tacit knowledge" among the technicians rather than formal blueprint updates, no two F-1 engines were completely identical. Each engine had its own undocumented quirks.There are still many other equipment in our modern world, such as the giant high-voltage transformers, with lifespans of many decades that are practically unique items.

The other point made in the parable was the Master - Apprentice relationship. The apprentice is able to learn, observe and practice during his apprenticeship. If this is not maintained, the skills will be lost when the Master passed. This was brought out in my 28 October 2026 post Three Case Studies on Maintenance.




No comments:

Post a Comment